Comparative Physiological Responses of Sheep and Goats to Combined Heat Stress and Water Restriction: A Systematic Review of Adaptive Mechanisms and Evidence Gaps
Downloads
Background: Sheep and goats in arid regions often face high temperatures and limited drinking water at the same time, but it is unclear how the two stressors interact and whether the two species respond differently. This review examined the experimental evidence. Methods: We conducted the literature search using PubMed, Europe PMC, AGRICOLA, and OpenAlex on 26th October 2026 and adhered to PRISMA 2020 guidelines for conducting the literature search. Original experiments were eligible if sheep or goats had water restricted or withheld under imposed heat[Tier 1] or under heat documented by the authors[Tier 2]. Reports from the same animals were counted once. Since designs and outcomes varied, a narrative synthesis using the outcome-direction coding technique, description of reported changes, and exploratory sign tests was attempted. Results: The searches returned 502 records; after removing 61 duplicates, 441 were screened, and 66 reports were assessed in full text. Thirty-five reports describing 30 independent cohorts were included. Nine cohorts were Tier 1 and 21 were Tier 2; 12 used sheep, 14 goats, and 4 both species. Cohorts were small[median 9 animals, range 5–42]. The most consistent results were the decline in body weight in 11 cohorts and in feed intake in 10, and the increase in plasma osmolality in 7[hematocrit increase in 5]. Thermoregulation changed in 6 cohorts, didn't change in 3, and was mixed in 6, and rose in 4 and fell in 5 with respect to respiration rate. Four of these cohorts performed a direct comparison of sheep and goats, and the evidence does not indicate there was any consistently clear superiority of either species. Conclusions: The available evidence mainly describes dehydration-related changes under hot conditions rather than proven adaptation. Only a few experiments applied both stressors, sample sizes were too few, and some reports may have shared animals. Factorial studies with adequate sample sizes, comparable protocols, and standardized heat reporting are needed.

